Health Insurance for Churches: An In-depth Look at Options
Churches face unique obstacles when it comes to providing healthcare benefits for their employees. Striking a balance between delivering value to their teams and maintaining financial sustainability requires innovative solutions. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the ever-evolving realm of health coverage for churches, shedding light on the advantages of Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs), which include Individual Coverage HRAs (ICHRAs) and Qualified Small Employer HRAs (QSEHRAs).
Discover the unique challenges faced by churches and religious institutions, including limited budgets and low salaries. Join us as we explore effective strategies to overcome these obstacles while maintaining responsible financial management.
This guide includes:
- Why benefits are important for church staff
- Options for Church health insurance
- The best option for health insurance for pastors of small churches
- How to choose church health insurance and pastor health insurance
- Options for health insurance allowance for ministers
- Other options for health insurance for religious organizations
- Whether or not churches can pay pastors health insurance
Harnessing the Power of HRAs: Supporting Employee Well-Being and Financial Sustainability in Churches
For the stability and wellbeing of a church community, it's critical to provide health insurance for pastors and employee benefits for church staff.
One such solution gaining traction is Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs). HRAs offer flexibility and cost control, allowing nonprofits to allocate their limited resources efficiently while attracting and retaining top talent.
In a report published by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), it was found that employers with comprehensive employee benefits, including health coverage, experience higher employee satisfaction and increased productivity. This demonstrates the importance of investing in employee well-being and the positive impact it can have on a church's mission.
These statistics and real-world examples underscore the significance of exploring innovative approaches to health benefits in the church world. HRAs provide a strategic tool for nonprofits to deliver valuable health coverage, overcome budgetary constraints, and attract and retain talented individuals dedicated to advancing their church's mission.
Join us as we delve into the world of health benefits for churches, examining the advantages of HRAs and how they can help churches strike a balance between financial sustainability, honoring the mission, and prioritizing employee well-being.
Balancing Your Church Mission, Stewardship, and Limited Resources
As a church, the core focus is undoubtedly on advancing the mission, taking care of your congregation and team, and making a positive impact. However, it's essential to acknowledge the challenges that come with limited budgets, typically low salaries, and the need to be good stewards of the funds. In this guide, we'll delve into these pain points and discuss strategies for churches to navigate these challenges effectively.
Putting Dollars Towards the Mission, Not Overhead
Churches understand the significance of directing funds towards their mission rather than overhead expenses. It's crucial to optimize the allocation of resources to ensure maximum impact. However, certain operational costs, such as employee benefits, cannot be overlooked. Health benefits, in particular, play a vital role in attracting and retaining top talent, which is essential for church success. Striking the right balance between minimizing overhead and providing competitive health benefits becomes a crucial consideration.
Being Good Stewards of Funds
Churches have a responsibility to be good stewards of the funds they raise through tithes and fundraising. Church members want to see their contributions utilized wisely and effectively. This means carefully evaluating expenditures and making strategic decisions. While it may be tempting to minimize costs across the board, it's essential to remember that investing in employee benefits, including health coverage, is an investment in the organization's long-term sustainability and success.
Navigating Church Pain Points
Limited budgets and typically low salaries present challenges for churches in various ways. One of the most significant pain points is attracting and retaining talented individuals who can contribute to the organization's mission. Churches often compete with for-profit entities that can offer more substantial compensation packages. As a result, finding and retaining skilled employees can be an ongoing struggle. Limited budgets can make it challenging to offer competitive benefits, further adding to the difficulty of attracting and retaining top talent.
Strategies for Success
While the pain points may seem daunting, there are strategies churches can employ to overcome these challenges and thrive:
- Strategic Budgeting: Prioritize spending on areas that have the most significant impact on your mission. This may involve finding cost-effective solutions for overhead expenses while ensuring essential employee benefits, such as health coverage, are not compromised.
- Creative Compensation Packages: Consider alternative forms of compensation, such as flexible work arrangements, professional development opportunities, or unique non-monetary perks that align with your employees' values and interests. This approach can help offset the limitations of low salary budgets.
- Maximizing Health Benefit Value: Partner with benefit providers who understand the unique needs of churches and offer cost-effective solutions without compromising quality. Platforms like Take Command can help churches navigate the complexities of health benefits, providing tailored options that fit within limited budgets.
- Highlighting the Mission: Emphasize the impact and purpose of the organization's work when recruiting and engaging employees. Churches often attract individuals who are passionate about making a difference, and leveraging that sense of purpose can help compensate for lower salary offerings.
By employing these strategies and prioritizing the effective utilization of resources, churches can overcome the pain points associated with limited budgets, low salaries, and the need for stewardship.
By providing competitive health benefits while being mindful of costs, churches can attract and retain talented individuals who share their vision and contribute to the organization's mission-driven success.
Begin designing your QSEHRA plan today and be set up in minutes
You could start reimbursing your employees tax-free sooner than you think.
Addressing the Unique Health Benefit Challenges in Churches with HRAs, ICHRAs, and QSEHRAs
Churches and religious institutions, with their distinctive mission and structural frameworks, often confront unique challenges when it comes to delivering health benefits to their employees. As these organizations strive to maximize their resources towards mission-centric activities, they are often in search of efficient, cost-effective solutions to provide robust health benefits.
Employee health benefits are an integral component of their overall compensation package, and their significance cannot be overstated. However, due to the distinct financial and structural intricacies of churches, conventional group health insurance plans may not always be the most viable or effective means to offer these benefits.
Enter HRAs – this category of employer-funded plans allows organizations to reimburse employees for out-of-pocket medical expenses and individual health insurance premiums on a tax-advantaged basis. Within the HRA universe, two specific types – the Individual Coverage HRA (ICHRA) and the Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSEHRA) – have emerged as particularly valuable tools for churches.
ICHRA and QSEHRA empower churches to effectively manage expenses while prioritizing the well-being of their employees. With their adaptable and scalable nature, ICHRAs are an ideal fit for larger organizations, while QSEHRAs provide a straightforward and cost-effective solution for smaller churches.
Exploring Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs)
Health benefits are a key factor in recruiting and retaining top-tier talent in any organization, including churches. But traditional health insurance plans may not always be the most cost-effective or flexible solution for these organizations. HRAs are a unique tool that could potentially transform the way churches approach health benefits.
What are HRAs?
Health Reimbursement Arrangements, or HRAs, are employer-funded health benefit plans that reimburse employees for out-of-pocket medical expenses, as well as premiums for individual health insurance policies. HRAs are not health insurance plans themselves; rather, they are a means for employers, including churches and other religious institutions, to help their employees pay for healthcare costs.
There are technically two "flavors" of HRAs that churches need to know about.
1. The Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement, or ICHRA, is a type of HRA that allows employers to reimburse employees for individual health insurance premiums and eligible medical expenses on a pre-tax basis. Unlike the QSEHRA, ICHRA has no annual contribution limits, and employers can offer ICHRAs to different classes of employees, with varying contribution amounts.
2. A Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSEHRA) is a specific type of HRA designed for small employers with fewer than 50 employees who do not offer a group health insurance plan. QSEHRA allows these employers to provide a set amount of tax-free money to their employees each year. Employees can use this money to purchase individual health insurance and cover other qualifying healthcare expenses.
The Advantages of HRAs for Churches
HRAs serve as a robust solution for churches navigating the complex landscape of health benefits.
- Cost Control: One of the most significant challenges churches face is budget predictability, particularly concerning healthcare costs. HRAs offer a solution to this issue by allowing churches to determine how much they will contribute to each employee's HRA account each year. This fixed contribution model enables churches to budget their healthcare expenses accurately and efficiently. The ability to control healthcare costs without compromising the quality of benefits offered to employees is an appealing feature of HRAs for churches.
- Flexibility: Another strength of HRAs lies in their flexibility. They allow churches to design a health benefit plan that aligns with their resources and the specific needs of their employees. HRAs can reimburse a broad spectrum of medical expenses, including doctor visits, prescription medications, and even health insurance premiums. This flexibility means that churches can provide a health benefits package that truly supports the wellbeing of their staff.
- Tax Efficiency: The tax advantages offered by HRAs cannot be understated. While the church as an entity might not be required to pay taxes, pastors and their staff are considered employees and will owe on taxes. HRA dollars are not subject to income tax, (or payroll tax or employer tax).
- Employee Choice: HRAs empower employees with greater choice and autonomy over their healthcare decisions. They can select the individual health insurance that best meets their needs and that of their families. This can lead to higher satisfaction levels and increased loyalty among employees.
-
Simplicity and Ease of Management: HRAs are simple to administer. Churches simply set their budget, choose a start date, and get back to running their church like a well oiled machine. Our clients on average spend less than an hour a month on their health benefits, meaning you don't have to have an entire HR department to roll out health benefits. Take Command handles everything, from onboarding employees to helping them enroll in health insurance to reporting and ongoing support.
-
Employee Empowerment: With HRAs, employees have the flexibility to choose their own health insurance plan that suits their personal needs and circumstances. This autonomy can lead to higher satisfaction and engagement among employees, which is crucial for attracting and retaining talent in the religious institution sector.
-
Legal Compliance: HRAs are fully compliant with the Affordable Care Act (ACA) rules, removing the risk of penalties and ensuring legal conformity. This compliance reassurance further adds to the appeal of HRAs for churches.
-
Integration with sharing ministries: Churches can reimburse employees for their sharing ministry costs with a QSEHRA (not ICHRA) as long as a Minimum Essential Coverage plan has also been set up.
Leveraging HRAs' cost-efficiency, flexibility, and tax benefits, churches can build a robust health benefits strategy. With Take Command’s expert guidance, churches can effectively manage HRAs, aligning their health benefits with their mission, ensuring employee wellness, and financial sustainability.
Case Study: New Britain ROOTS
New Britain ROOTS, a small nonprofit based in Connecticut, promotes food security and empowered eating choices through local advocacy and education initiatives. While it's not a church, it shares many of the same pain points as churches and the solution is positioned for nonprofits and churches alike.
With a tight-knit team and financial constraints, New Britain ROOTS was confronted with a daunting obstacle: how to offer cost-effective healthcare benefits for their dedicated staff.
Joey Listro, the Executive Director, faced the harsh reality of expensive group health insurance plans. Recognizing the need for a competitive benefits package to attract and retain skilled employees, the growing organization grappled with the challenge of achieving this without breaking their budget.
The Quest for an Affordable Solution
After exploring multiple alternatives, Joey serendipitously discovered the QSEHRA. As the sole full-time team member, the exorbitant cost of traditional employer plans, which were nearly five times higher than QSEHRA, posed a significant obstacle.
However, the lack of familiarity with QSEHRA posed its own challenges. Joey faced the task of introducing this unknown concept to his board of directors, who were unsure about its legal implications. As a nonprofit organization, obtaining the board's approval was essential, requiring Joey to provide accurate information to align everyone's understanding.
Enter Take Command
That's where Take Command stepped in, offering guidance and educational resources about QSEHRA. With this support, Joey was able to clarify the benefits of QSEHRA to his board, gaining their approval to move forward with the setup.
Take Command’s team continued to assist Joey throughout the setup process, providing a simple, user-friendly platform for managing the QSEHRA. As a result, New Britain ROOTS successfully implemented their QSEHRA in January, currently reimbursing premiums only.
Joey shares, "The setup was quick and simple, and reporting and reimbursements are easy as well."
The Impact of QSEHRA
By implementing QSEHRA, New Britain ROOTS was able to offer affordable healthcare benefits to its dedicated staff, ensuring their well-being and satisfaction. This decision not only enabled them to attract and retain skilled employees but also positioned them competitively in the job market, setting the stage for their future expansion plans.
This case study serves as a prime example of how nonprofits, despite facing limited resources, can harness the power of QSEHRA to offer cost-effective and long-lasting health benefits to their team, ultimately bolstering their mission and fostering growth.
Which HRA is right for you?
What's the best health insurance for pastors of small churches?
Small churches have an HRA designed specifically for them. It's called a Qualified Small Employer HRA and it's for churches with less than 50 full time equivalent employees.
How much does church health insurance cost?
Great question. Church health insurance offered through an HRA can be set at whatever budget the church can afford. There isn't restrictions on the limit. We recommend assessing the local insurance market, the needs of the pastor and team, and working with an HRA administrator like Take Command to custom fit an HRA to your budget and team.
Do HRAs work for pastor health insurance?
Yes! Absolutely. Churches want to take care of their pastors, and an HRA is an excellent way to do that. The pastor can choose the plan he wants that works best for his family, and he will get reimbursed on his paycheck.
Do churches have to offer health insurance to pastors?
If the church has more than 50 employees, it's likely that they have to offer health insurance to their staff. However, most churches are small than that. Even though offering health insurance to pastors and staff aren't required, it's an investment in the quality and long-term stability of a church to keep great ministerial talent around.
What's the recommended health insurance allowance for ministers?
This is a great question. Health insurance allowance for ministers really depends on a few factors - where the church is located, what the local health insurance market looks like, what the pastors family is comprised of, and what their needs are. By looking at the costs of local plan premiums, it's easy to pinpoint a range that would be comfortable. If you want to reimburse for medical expenses on top of an HRA to just cover the premium, that's an added bonus for the pastor.
How much time does it take to manage health insurance for religious institutions?
We get it! Church employees are busy! Luckily, HRAs are hands off and easy to manage. Take Command's platform handles all the heavy lifting and most of our clients spend less than an hour a month administering their benefits.
Churches comprise roughly 10% of our clients.
Churches are well suited for HRAs and HRAs are strategically positioned to address common church pain points when it comes to benefits and budget.
Take Command Streamlines Church Health Benefits Management
By partnering with Take Command, small churches can overcome the limitations and effortlessly implement and manage a QSEHRA. Our comprehensive HRA administration service simplifies compliance, setup, and ongoing management, enabling churches to offer competitive health benefits despite limited resources. These benefits not only boost employee satisfaction and talent retention but also contribute to the long-term success of the church.
Flexible Designs
No more one-size fits all plans! HRA plans for churches can be customized and designed to achieve your church’s goals.
Simple Administration
Take Command simplifies the process by automatically generating the essential documents required by your church employees. Additionally, it assists them in effortlessly searching for and enrolling in a suitable plan online.
On-Ramp to Benefits
80% of our small business clients are net new to benefits. An HRA is an affordable, simple way to offer scalable benefits to your church team on your budget.
Making the Choice: Best Health Benefits for Your Church
When it comes to selecting the best health benefits plan for your church, several factors should be taken into consideration. By carefully evaluating these factors, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your church's size, financial capacity, and the specific needs of your employees.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Health Benefits Plan
- Organization Size: The size of your nonprofit organization is a crucial factor in selecting the most suitable health benefits plan. Smaller organizations may find it more manageable to opt for traditional group health plans, while larger organizations can leverage the flexibility provided by HRAs, such as ICHRAs or QSEHRAs, to their advantage.
- Financial Considerations: It is essential to evaluate your church's financial resources when making a decision about health benefits. HRAs are an appealing option for nonprofits with limited financial capacity as they offer cost control and predictable budgeting. On the other hand, traditional group health plans may require a larger financial investment but provide comprehensive coverage.
- Recognizing the individual needs and preferences of your employees is of utmost importance. Take into account factors such as their demographics, healthcare needs, and their emphasis on flexibility and choice. This valuable insight will guide you in determining whether HRAs or traditional group health plans are the optimal choice for your church.
Guidelines for Choosing the Most Suitable Plan
- Evaluate Cost and Budget: Carefully analyze the costs associated with each health benefits plan, including premiums, contributions, and potential out-of-pocket expenses for both the church, pastor team, and employees. Consider the long-term financial sustainability and alignment with your church's mission.
- Assess Employee Preferences: Survey your employees to understand their preferences and needs regarding healthcare coverage. Consider their desire for choice, flexibility, and the value they place on comprehensive coverage versus cost-sharing.
- Seek Expert Guidance: Consult with benefits advisors, insurance brokers, or HR professionals who specialize in church health insurance. Their expertise can provide valuable insights and help navigate the complexities of different plan options.
- Consider Compliance and Administration: Assess the administrative demands and compliance responsibilities linked to each plan. Gauge your organization's ability to manage the required documentation, reporting, and legal obligations. If necessary, contemplate teaming up with a health benefits administration service like Take Command for efficient administration and support in meeting compliance requirements.
By carefully considering these factors and following these guidelines, churches can choose the health benefits plan that best suits their organization's size, financial capacity, and the specific needs of their employees. Making an informed decision ensures that your church can provide valuable, competitive health benefits that support your employees' wellbeing while aligning with your mission and financial goals.
Navigating Employee Benefits for Churches: Requirements, Exemptions, and Tax Credits
Churches are not generally required by law to offer benefits to their employees. However, there are certain requirements and exemptions to consider in the context of nonprofit organizations and their employee benefits. Let's explore these aspects further:
Are churches required to offer benefits?
Churches are not mandated to provide employee benefits, such as health insurance, by federal law. Unlike many for-profit companies subject to the Affordable Care Act's employer mandate, nonprofits are generally exempt from this requirement. However, it's important to note that state laws and regulations may vary, so churches should consult local regulations to ensure compliance.
Are there exemptions for churches?
Churches may qualify for certain exemptions and alternatives when it comes to employee benefits. For example, some religiously affiliated nonprofits may be exempt from certain contraceptive coverage requirements based on religious objections. It's crucial for churches to understand their legal obligations and any exemptions that may apply to their specific circumstances.
Are there tax credits for churches?
While churches may not be subject to the same tax credit programs as for-profit businesses, there are tax incentives and credits available to help offset costs associated with employee benefits. For instance, the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit is available for eligible small employers, including nonprofits, that provide health insurance coverage to their employees. Churches should consult with tax professionals or benefits advisors to explore potential tax credits and incentives specific to their organization.
To successfully navigate the intricate legal landscape and meet the specific requirements and exemptions related to employee benefits, it is crucial for churches to exercise caution. Seeking the guidance of legal and tax advisors who specialize in churches can provide invaluable assistance, ensuring compliance with relevant laws and regulations. Moreover, exploring tax credits and incentives can assist churches in mitigating the costs associated with providing employee benefits, thereby further supporting their financial sustainability and mission-driven objectives.
Guiding Churches towards the Right Health Benefits Plan with Take Command
Providing health insurance for churches is a critical aspect of attracting and retaining top talent while promoting the wellbeing of employees. However, navigating the complexities of health benefits can be challenging for these organizations. In this article, we have explored the potential solutions offered by HRAs, including ICHRAs and QSEHRAs, for churches. HRAs provide several benefits for nonprofits, such as cost control, flexibility, and tax efficiency.
ICHRAs offer customization and scalability, while QSEHRAs are suitable for smaller organizations seeking simplicity. These HRAs empower churches to design personalized benefits that align with their financial capacity and the specific needs of their employees.
Throughout the decision-making process, churches should carefully evaluate their unique needs and circumstances. Factors such as organization size, financial capacity, and employee preferences should be considered when selecting a health benefits plan. Seeking guidance from experts in the field and leveraging trusted partners like Take Command can provide churches with the knowledge and support needed to make informed decisions.
Take Command offers comprehensive services to help churches navigate the complexities of HRAs, ensuring compliance, simplifying administration, and providing personalized guidance. With their expertise, churches can maximize the benefits of HRAs while mitigating potential drawbacks, enabling them to offer competitive health benefits that contribute to the overall success of their mission.
Our experienced and friendly team is ready to help you on your health benefits journey.
How much will you save with an HRA?
Since QSEHRA reimbursements are tax-free, churches can enjoy considerable savings. Check out our QSEHRA tax savings calculator to get a savings estimate.
Let's talk through your HRA questions
Susanne is a copywriter specializing in the health and wellness industry. Before starting her own business, she spent nearly a decade at a marketing agency doing all of the things – advisor, copywriter, SEO strategist, social media specialist, and project manager. That experience gives her a unique understanding of how the consumer-focused content she writes flows into each marketing piece. Susanne lives in Oklahoma City with her husband and two daughters. She loves being outdoors, exercising and reading.
